When Grants Become a Problem: Why Creating Donors Should Come First

Being approved for a grant can feel like a massive win for nonprofits, providing crucial funding for specific projects. However, leaning too heavily on grants can create serious challenges, limiting a nonprofit’s growth, stability, and connection to its community. Therefore, it is best to see grants as “bonus” funding, while building a donor base—a community of people invested in your mission—should be a primary focus as a nonprofit leader. By focusing on connecting with your community and direct supporters of your nonprofit’s cause, you can not only fund the mission but foster deeper connections.

Grants are highly competitive—only 1 in 10 applications receives funding​. Even if a grant is awarded, it often comes with an expiration date. When that funding ends, nonprofits are forced to rush for new grants, creating a cycle of constant uncertainty and worry.

A dedicated donor base, on the other hand, provides steady support that doesn’t disappear after a project ends. With the financial backing of regular donors, nonprofits can plan confidently for the future, knowing they have a supportive community behind them. And with the stability a donor base provides, nonprofits can put more energy into creating impactful programs rather than chasing temporary funds.

Most grants come with strict rules on how funds must be used. In fact, more than 50% of nonprofit leaders say these restrictions make it challenging to cover essential costs like rent, staff, or emergencies​. This lack of flexibility can keep nonprofits from responding quickly to evolving community needs or sustaining their core mission.

A donor base provides much-needed freedom. Donors who support your mission often contribute unrestricted funds, allowing nonprofits to use resources where they’re needed most. This flexibility not only strengthens the organization’s ability to operate effectively but empowers it to respond creatively to urgent needs. With community-driven support, nonprofits can address issues as they arise, creating a stronger impact together with their supporters.

Applying for and managing grants is complex. Nonprofits have to dedicate time and resources to filling out applications, tracking impact, and creating detailed reports. For smaller nonprofits, this administrative load can strain limited resources. With up to 25% of grant applications denied due to minor errors​, this process can become frustrating and unproductive.

Building a donor base, by contrast, emphasizes community connection rather than paperwork. Cultivating relationships with donors means sharing the real impact of your work how you want to share it and creating ways for them to get involved. Supporters become part of the mission, seeing themselves as active partners in making a difference. This engagement builds loyalty, strengthens community ties, and fosters a collaborative approach to solving societal challenges.

Grants can sometimes be a helpful boost for special projects, but they shouldn’t be the backbone of a nonprofit’s funding strategy. Building a donor base creates stability, flexibility, and, most importantly, community connection. When supporters feel like they’re part of the mission, they become advocates, volunteers, and champions for the cause, creating a shared sense of purpose.

By putting donor relationships first, nonprofits are no longer “going it alone” but working alongside a community of people dedicated to the same vision. Grants are a valuable addition, but a strong donor base is what will help your organization grow, connect, and thrive for years to come.

‍